Of course actor/singer Reeve Carney is the man to take on the entirety of the world’s most famous cult movie. He played handyman Riff Raff in the 2016 Fox movie re-imagining of the late-night institution. But he also played Orpheus in Hadestown and Spider-Man for three years in Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark.

Beyond his Broadway bona fides, he’s also known from his many film and TV turns, including his role as Dorian Gray for Showtime’s Penny Dreadful. He’s been in Michael Jackson recordings, a Taylor Swift video, and U2 tours. And he’s on tap to portray Jeff Buckley for that singer-songwriter’s biopic. As such, we think he’s got this.