Last fall's deadly Camp Fire has brought renewed questions about whether towns in high risk areas like Paradise, Calif., should even be rebuilt.
Barry Long tried to squash those immediately recently, as he kicked off a crowded town hall meeting at the Paradise Alliance Church.
"One of the first questions we get is, 'are they really going to rebuild Paradise?'," Long says. "And we say that's not a question, [the city] council made an immediate decision [that] we're going to rebuild Paradise."
That was met by a resounding applause from a large crowd of anxious Paradise residents. Long's firm, Urban Design Associates, was hired by the town council to develop a long term recovery plan for Paradise. They've begun holding meetings — the latest scheduled for March 19 — discussing with residents how they think their town should be rebuilt.
Many people have had to leave Paradise after about 90 percent of the town — almost 19,000 structures — burned to the ground last November in the Camp Fire, which also claimed 85 lives. But for the few who do remain and are eager to begin rebuilding, Long sought to give them reassurances: you can't just abandon a community that's been a fixture in the Sierra Nevada foothills since the the 1800s, he said.
"It took 140 years to build Paradise and obviously things did survive, like the church here," Long said.
Urban Design Associates also consulted for the state of Louisiana after Hurricane Katrina. And that's what this still unfolding crisis is starting to be likened to: a rural Katrina. One big parallel emerging so far is anxiety over gentrification. Once Paradise is rebuilt, there's resounding agreement it will have much tougher, fire safe building codes. And that won't be cheap.
"We just need affordable living and our home back," said Cathe Wood.
Anxiety over gentrification
Wood has lived in Paradise for thirty years. She's planning to rebuild, but is still applying for permits and dealing with insurance claims. For now anyway, her job is still in Paradise. She works at an accounting firm that didn't burn. Her home and her family weren't so lucky.
"I lost everything," Wood says. "All my family members are homeless, scattered throughout California, I just want to come home."
Paradise was a haven for retirees and others who couldn't afford the city or just wanted to live in the country. Like a lot of western towns, it grew too quickly — without a lot of planning and scant zoning. Mobile home parks, tract houses, fast food restaurants were packed into overgrown forests.
Cathe Wood hopes something good will come out of all this.
"We have a great opportunity up here for a complete reset," she says.
A complete reset, but will it be affordable?
"Paradise is not going to be the same as it was," says Jody Jones, the town's mayor.
As the recovery process moves forward, Jones and other town officials insist they're trying to balance rebuilding smarter while also not mandating expensive changes. But they've never done this before and they're learning as they go.
"I don't know that I can give any assurances it's not going to be gentrified," Jones says. "Because in some sense of the word what people mean by that is new, and everything we build is going to be new, it's going to be different."
The good news is Paradise has time to get it right. The scale of this disaster is enormous, even just cleaning it up and removing all the hazardous debris could take more than a year. So it's not as if the town can just be repopulated and rebuilt immediately as it was.
The cleanup only began in earnest a couple weeks ago.
At another forum in nearby Chico, a group of third year architecture students from Cal Poly San Luis Obispo may have some answers. They've put up poster boards showing architectural renderings of energy efficient, and "fire-wise" municipal buildings. There are proposed, newly redesigned, wider street grids for safer evacuations. And neighborhoods are drawn with more cleared out, open space between smaller, modern and up to code homes.
A few curious members of the public mingled around the presentation talking to students who said their models were still a work in progress.
"We're trying to figure out a different way to rearrange the town so that it better suits the inhabitants and brings new people to Paradise" says Allessandro Zanghi.
They're calling it a "re-imagined Paradise." The class typically consults for underserved communities. And when the Camp Fire happened, the curriculum was re-designed to cater to Paradise and surrounding burnt-out towns.
For Zanghi, it's been a challenge trying to redesign proposals that preserve Paradise's rural character. But he says it's a misnomer that rebuilding or redeveloping a mountain community like this will result in a more expensive town.
"It's really important to have architecture be more than just luxury high rises," Zanghi says. "It should be things that help a community grow and flourish."
Affordability and gentrification are some of the more heated topics emerging so far in the town's preliminary discussions. At some cantankerous city council meetings, fire survivors have argued with officials over whether they could put campers on burnt-out properties and how FEMA resources will be allocated.
The students' instructor, Stacey White, says those are tough conversations that have to happen. But what's going on here is separate. These kids can take the time to take a 30,000 foot view of the rebuilding project and hopefully inspire a little hope for the community amid all the other setbacks.
"But [these] students have an ability to step back and think, 'what if we did this right?'," White says. "They're focused on affordability, resiliency and permanence; really investing in the place so we don't relive this again in ten years."
Her class will soon hand over their plans to the town. After four long months of stress and anxiety in this community, the students hope the crisis can also be looked at as an opportunity for Paradise, and they want to help.
You won’t find a paywall here. Come as often as you like — we’re not counting. You’ve found a like-minded tribe that cherishes what a free press stands for. If you can spend another couple of minutes making a pledge of as little as $5, you’ll feel like a superhero defending democracy for less than the cost of a month of Netflix.